Christian Nation?

According to research revealed in this Slate story, Americans are twice as likely to report regularly attending Christian church services as to actually go to church services with any sort of regularity. Which, apparently, means that we’re no more religious than, say, Europe.

But of course, there’s more than meets the eye, right? A few thoughts:

1) Since we’re basically a nation of functioning secularism, it doesn’t make sense (as if it really ever did) to call ourselves a “Christian” nation. It, of course, makes even less sense to blame all of our societal ills on atheists, (h/t Alise) as this poor letter-to-the-editor author does.

2) There’s that disturbing trend of mixing religion (and particularly, Christianity) with nationalism/patriotism. One should not confuse one for the other. Scary path, that is*.

3) Going to church – or not going to church – doesn’t make one a Christian. Following Christ does (and although different faith traditions have differing opinions on what that means, I will only say that simply reciting a prayer is *not* following Jesus). Within that, though, I do think that it’s important for people who follow Jesus to be at church – or more importantly, to be church. To be in communion with others who share in the stories, the tragedies, the heart breaks, the hope, the lives, the burials, and the bread and wine of Jesus’ body and blood. I do believe that the act of faith-community is an essential one.

But… I’m meeting more and more people who do not feel welcome in a church body. And that troubles me. It troubles me that people do not feel welcomed in the one place where they should feel invited. After all, wasn’t it Jesus who gave refuge to the adulteress when the townspeople wanted to stone her (and curiously left out her partner)? Wasn’t it Jesus who made the dreadful, scary, mixed-race Samaritan the hero of one of his most famous stories? Wasn’t it Jesus that welcomed the outcast sinners and tax collectors and fishermen and zealots and women into his close circle? Wasn’t it Jesus who went out of his way to touch the poisonous lepers? Wasn’t it Jesus who moved the merchants out of the temple so that the lame and blind can come in?

How, then, can Christian churches – who are to live as the communal embodiment of Jesus – not be able to embrace those who think/act/look/believe just a bit differently? Many of our churches have such a hard time with people with mental tics (depression, bipolar disorder, schizophrenia), for example. Is this because they don’t fit in with our particular notions of normalized Americans? Americans first, Christians second? Or is there another kingdom that Christians belong to? Is there another national identity that trumps all others – in which there is neither slave nor free, male nor female, Greek, pagan, or Jew?

*</Lame Yoda reference.>


3 thoughts on “Christian Nation?

  1. wonderfully stated. I couldn’t agree more with your observations about our “christian nation” and lack of actually followers. I also agree that church should be a refuge for those who do not follow Jesus… but as you say, something does need to change…

  2. Thanks, Jas. It is fascinating how people delude themselves that they are regular church attenders. I did a survey last year, asking people who had not attended our church for a year why they stopped coming. I got amazing answers like, “Stopped coming? We are regular members!” or “We love this church. We’re members.” Two problems: we do not have formal membership; and they do not actually come. Bizarre. I guess regular attendance is in the eyes of the beholder.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s